Originally posted by: Je
You can't call the bullshit SE editions a make over. III is much better than IV went IV should be better than III. Listen up, leave the story of IV the same just change little thing like obi not recognizing the droids, him telling luke that his father wanted him to have his lightsaber, and the WEAK ASS battle of vader & obi. V story really doesn't need to be changed just maybe little parts like luke getting tongued by his sister and the vader fight. How did luke even put up a fight in V with vader and he just learned about the force. In II anakin learned the force for 10 years and didn't even put up a fight with the count. In III anakin took on all of these jedi in the temple and won (one scene they show him fighting three at one time). So how in the hell did weak as luke even get a hit off. It kind of made vader look weak. VI story is good but the part I have a problem is obi saying he found anakin and took it upon HIMself to train anakin. That part really needs to change because it makes obi look like a liar. Its so much they can do to make IV,V and VI better by making them over instead of fucking with the originals but I would rather them fuck with the originals if they don't make them over. (to many errors in IV,V and VI)
You can't call the bullshit SE editions a make over. III is much better than IV went IV should be better than III. Listen up, leave the story of IV the same just change little thing like obi not recognizing the droids, him telling luke that his father wanted him to have his lightsaber, and the WEAK ASS battle of vader & obi. V story really doesn't need to be changed just maybe little parts like luke getting tongued by his sister and the vader fight. How did luke even put up a fight in V with vader and he just learned about the force. In II anakin learned the force for 10 years and didn't even put up a fight with the count. In III anakin took on all of these jedi in the temple and won (one scene they show him fighting three at one time). So how in the hell did weak as luke even get a hit off. It kind of made vader look weak. VI story is good but the part I have a problem is obi saying he found anakin and took it upon HIMself to train anakin. That part really needs to change because it makes obi look like a liar. Its so much they can do to make IV,V and VI better by making them over instead of fucking with the originals but I would rather them fuck with the originals if they don't make them over. (to many errors in IV,V and VI)
-Obi-Wan doesn't "remember" the Droids because he is covering up. Obi-Wan's words say one thing, but his face says another.
-Obi-Wan told Luke that his Father wanted him to have his lightsaber because it was less painful than the truth, and a convenient plot device to get Luke a lightsaber.
-What do you want? Obi-Wan doing backflips when he's like, 80 years old? The Jedi/Sith are aging and less powerful than they were during I-III. No leap of faith there.
-Luke never got tongued by Leia you over-exaggerator you - it was a kiss on the mouth, but moreso to make Han jealous. Mission accomplished.
-Luke beat Vader in V because he gave in to his anger for a brief moment, and then retracted his feelings when he saw that he was becoming just like his Father. If you want visual proof look at the cut - close up of Vader's severed hand, close up of Luke's. Pretty compelling, no?
-Obi-Wan isn't a liar to claim that he tried to train Anakin. He promised Qui-Gon he would continue Ani's training and he did. Just because it wasn't shown in any of the films doesn't mean it didn't happen. The dialogue and forced chemistry between Obi-Wan and Anakin is supposed to convey the Master-Student/Friend relationship.
-What you call errors, I call depth.