I just downloaded the first disc. I haven't watched it through yet, but I spot checked a couple of places where your edits occured. I think your edit works much better with its showing Gandalf reading about the major battle instead of just seeing it in the opening scene. The 17 years later subscript and the "The Ring Goes South" title screen were nice touchs as well. I have two comments: first, is there anyplace where the title "The Ring Sets Out" appears in the beginning? If not, perhaps just underneath the "Fellowship" would be cool, and second why no 5.1 sound? These movies have an amazing soundtrack and I would thought you would have included this. Anyway, take my comments with a grain of salt as I haven't watched it yet
but I do think this will be pretty amazing!