I want it "ugly." I don't want anything but a very minimal visual cleanup to get rid of excessive grain and age. But I want all the matte lines, all the transparancies, and all the garbage mattes still there. And those aren't nearly as apparent as they were in the 2004 DVDs because the picture was cleaned up so much that the flaws became obvious. If they're true in saying the picture won't be as good as the 2004 DVDs, then I'll be happy. But they shouldn't try to remove anything. If I get these DVDs, and the rancor's matte line is gone, I will be pissed because that will not be the original version.