Originally posted by: ricarleite
What I am proposing is having a televised debate between God, who would come to Earth by using someone's image (I propose a 1960s Don Knotts in a black suit), and about 5 people who are currently suffering. One with a crushing loneliness and depression, the one with health problems and in a pain beyond any medical help, the one who has lost wife and children in an accident, the poor one with no money to even buy food or clothes, and the handicapped one. They all ask to God why are their lifes so miserable, and He must reply. then God can ask them if they have been good and loving people, and they must reply. The people watching the debate can judge if God deserves our worship, and if we should go to church and follow His words, OR if we should agree with Nietzche and abandon this idiotic concept of a all-powerful all-knowing all-loving God.
If you really wanted this debate to take place in all objectivity, you shouldn't have coloured your last sentence so much...