btw, i will give more details, if you'd like. just ask.
----------------
OT.Com Fan Edit Grading Scale
Please grade on scale of 0-100 on each category. Final Score is the average of the categories.
Name of Film and Editor: ADM's Ep 1
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 150
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 66
Additional Comments: Edit was very clean, but at parts, one can tell where cuts were made. Possibly ADM's first edit? Definitely can tell who has done this by editing style.
----------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM ep2
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 160
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 68
Additional Comments: Edit better quality than ep 1. cuts much better. integration of deleted scenes superbly done.
--------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM ep3
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 95
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 95
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 180
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 74
Additional Comments: in my opinion, the best star wars edit in the group. Great incorporation of deleted scenes, as well editing redundancies.
-------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM ep4
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 85
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 140
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 63
Additional Comments: Judge's opinion only! this movie did not need an edit. i understand, however, why the editor decided this. Technically, great job. clean cuts. streamlined the film.
--------------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM ep5
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 87
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 150
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 65.4
Additional Comments: I have to admit, watching the original, i noticed redundancies. ADM took care of these very well. also, he took care of the pseudo incest. good job. still seemed a bit blocky at parts, edit-wise.
----------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM ep 6
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 82
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 180
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 70.4
Additional Comments: finale of the saga. edits complemented the story very well. did not notice any harsh cuts. very nice indeed.
--------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM Hannibal
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 95
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 180
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 73
Additional Comments: Great edit. The exposition of the characters definitely make more sense. Seems to lag, but is to be expected with the integration of deleted scenes.
----------------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM Pearl Harbor
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 90
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 200
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 76
Additional Comments: One of the finest edits done. perfect. so good, my wife (a history teacher) uses it to teach her class. especially liked the bar scene. No extras, hence the low score.
----------
Name of Film and Editor: ADM Star Wars Saga
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 89.5
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 89.5
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 95
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 160
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 86.8
Additional Comments: I decided to combine this set as a saga and include the spoofs and musical journey addendums as extras. the above are the figures.
--------------
Name of Film and Editor: CBB Boogeyman
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 75
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 80
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 50
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 180
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 77
Additional Comments: video cleaner than dezionized, and audio much better. extras are nice, including fanedited trailers. edit was beautiful.
------------
Name of Film and Editor: CBB High Tension
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 80
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 85
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 60
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 190
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 83
Additional Comments: i now know what "Minus One Edit" stands for. great choice in film. edit was superb. only gripe i have is the lack of subs in this release. It's a good thing i know french.
-------------
Name of Film and Editor: CBB Matrix
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 70
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 70
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 85
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 198
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 84.6
Additional Comments: I loved this edit. It rekindled my love for the matrix movies. the video and audio were a tad subpar. it looked like it was compressed as a divx/xvid file at some point. audio was a tad low as well. but any edit that has subs and a couple kickass trailers is a ok in my book.
-------------
Name of Film and Editor: GC Batman and Robin
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 95
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 200
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 77
Additional Comments: great edit! who knew one could turn a crappy film like this and turn it to something viewable (not perfect, but who can chip perfection from this block of nonsense?). just a little over an hour long, chock full of batman goodness.
--------------
Name of Film and Editor: RB Willard
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 90
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 95
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 150
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 67
Additional Comments: Edit is decent. cut together very well, but this edit primarily consists of just adding deleted scenes back in. lags the film a lot.
-------------
Name of Film and Editor: rec1aimer starwars saga
Video (anamorphic, clean picture, etc): 75
Audio (clean sound, extra dubbings clean, etc): 60
Extras (bonus materials, commentary, etc): 0
(Multiply Score By Two) Edit (innovation, editing style, etc): 50
Divide by 5 to get the Final Score: 37
Additional Comments: I really wanted to like this edit. the idea was great and innovative. the execution, however, was not. it's a first try, however, and i'm sure his next project will improve by leaps and bounds.