so basically what you are saying is judging needs to fit a particular criteria. well, that's fine and dandy, except we are confined by what the editor has produced and submitted to us. Different judges have different opinions to what they would consider 100%. That's what made this contest fun. To see what the other judges thought of it. We decided to keep the scoring vague for that reason. we did not put limitations on what was considered superb quality because we figured the judge could make that distinction (and they have).

Billy, this is an open forum, and I respect your, and everyone elses, opinion. If you would like to post your review, please do so.