logo Sign In

Post #195771

Author
The Bizzle
Parent topic
THE FAN EDIT CONTEST HAS A WINNER !!! REVIEWS IN OFF TOPIC FORUM
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/195771/action/topic#195771
Date created
26-Mar-2006, 7:32 PM
LOL. Why? Because you got a crap review? Dude, my above analogy (the crap one) stands. You spent a lot of time on sub-par work. I'm not gonna give you credit JUST because you spent a lot of time on it. The work has to be GOOD. It wasn't good, for the most part. Those aren't insults, those are valid criticisms. if they sting, you should examine that, and examine why you do what you do, because not a single one of those edits felt at all like you cared as much about improving the movie as you did putting a candy coated sheen on everything else.

And there's plenty of details in those little capsule reviews. Don't blame Dayv for the fact that I didn't like your stuff, and don't browbeat him about his contest because you got a bad score. Besides, after doing a google search or two, I discovered you shouldn't at ALL be new to criticism like this anyway, at least judging by some of the comments I've read on various torrent sites and messageboards.

I mean--why, when you're chopping as much of Matrix up as you can, do you leave EVERY fight sequence in, and then not even TOUCH Trinity's death? About the only thing I think you guys pulled off REALLY well was the Trinity infiltration/rescue from reloaded.