logo Sign In

Post #195539

Author
Billy Mahoney
Parent topic
THE FAN EDIT CONTEST HAS A WINNER !!! REVIEWS IN OFF TOPIC FORUM
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/195539/action/topic#195539
Date created
25-Mar-2006, 2:22 PM
Besides of this contest being a true embarrasment for everyone involved by just not presenting a winner and the contestants in an accurate way, I can still absolutely not agree on the outcome and since I don't get to read any cards and also no one else says anything at all, it may be my turn, since I am just a viewer and consumer of fan edits. I have been talking to a lot of friends meanwhile about this contest and they all agree on one thing: an extended edition with no extras is neither innovative nor special. As I stated before, it is very well done, but that's about it (I am not attacking you or your work here, ADM, I am a fan of yours for a long time). What other movies did we have: Batman and Robin De-Assified. Isn't that innovation? Isn't that cool and unique from the title to the making? And what about Matrix DeZIONized? This is by far the most popular edit besides the Phantom Edit. It is not perfectly done, I agree to that, but it combines two bad movies to one good movie, it is famous and loved by many and it has a new beginning, new end credits, subtitles, chapters, animated menu, trailer and an own cover design, it must have taken months to finish that and it is well done (just my humble opinion). Sorry, but what is wrong here? Personal problems because Boon23 was complaining about the delay (and I think he was right there)? It can't be that, can it? Just my 2 cents. Now hunt me down, but you won't kill me.