That's not what we are saying at all. If you've seen anything else that Hayden has been in, and compare that performance to AOTC and ROTS, there's a BIG difference. The fact that this can be said about any of the big actors in the PT says LOADS about the direction - not to mention what is known about Lucas' infamous (fabuloso?) directing method of "Faster, more intense" method.

Everyone (except for Jar-Jar) acts like they are in a bottle. The only ones who are still able to provide any depth to their characters despite this are McDiarmid and Neeson.