i may be a die hard hayden fan (and yeah it probably all started with his fabulous good looks) but i can admit that he did a pretty weak job in attack of the clones. i was disappointed. but it was lucas who write the stupid sappy lines. so i think if it's anyone to blame, it is both of them, lucas for hiring pretty-boy hayden, and hayden for just not fitting the part, nor acting well in it. but i mean it all comes down to the director... so even if hayden was doing a better job, if it wasn't up to georgie's standards, CUT and redo the scene...