Anything that promotes quality above quantity has to be good. However, I agree with Jay that post limiting should not be automatic on sign-up, but only used as a punishment. This would make a fair and visible progression towards a ban. Titles were always a nice touch and a free-for-all would just be having two nicknames rather than one. I like the idea of the 6 month (or a year) Padawan title, followed by titles assigned by the mods (and anyone else who had reached the Jedi Council). Number of posts should not be a factor at all IMHO, though they should be recorded for those who want to know.