Doetzer's edits are as fascinating as they are silly. He's got some fun ideas, which are very entertaining to watch and the kind you'd get from listening to the radio drama while high. It's a lot of nonsense bearing no resemblance to the original Star Wars script, yet watchable.
I (with the vast help and research of Sluggo and others) worked as thoughtfully as I could to slap deleted and making of footage into the film in an entertaining manner. None of the deleted footage is finished or in releasable quality, and it's all quite silly, so it was necessary to give the film a more documentary/comedic tone.
I am offended when someone asks "What is the best Episode 4 Edit to incorporate deleted footage?" and then adds, "Oh yeah, besides that."
The Biggs footage can't be put into a straightforward movie version because it's crap quality and hasn't been released in the same quality and etc etc etc etc etc.
This is as close as you'd want to get. And yeah, I do feel slightly insulted.