Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
To be honest, I rarely set through any of the films anymore. Now, I mostly read the books/comics (which I find superior to the films). If it weren't for the EU, Star Wars would be pretty dry, IMHO. And, IMO, all of the films have an equal replay value. I really don't think ANH is any better than, say, TPM.
Originally posted by: Scout trooper
Yes, you're 17 years old and we're supposed to take your opinion seriously.
Well, JDs post was meant to represent the opinions of young people toward the PT, so I think that allows my post to be taken into consideration.
I have to agree, to me the saga is like putting a square peg into a round hole it doesnt fit IMO, I can watch the Prequel films if I feel like it but I dont find them as enjoyable and dont have the same replay value as the Original films and I also notice the quality drop from the original films especially Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back.
Yes, you're 17 years old and we're supposed to take your opinion seriously.
Well, JDs post was meant to represent the opinions of young people toward the PT, so I think that allows my post to be taken into consideration.
Originally posted by: Mr Bungle
Originally posted by: Jambe Davdar
A very odd post I must say.
Isn't that all pretty obvious from simply watching the films or moreover listening to Lucas's endless rhetoric.
I still have big problems linking the two Trilogies. They seem like chalk and cheese to me.
The OT was inventive, original (well, traditional with a twist), funny, clever and above all entertaining. The PT for me was trite and derivitive and lacked all that made the OT such a big part of childhood. I really don't think that the PT will grow with it's child audience the way that the OT did with my generation. My newphews have grown up with the PT and have already moved on. They still like the OT but say that the PT is good for their little cousin - aged 4.
I don't think this TV series will do much to help matters either.
JD
Originally posted by: Jambe Davdar
A very odd post I must say.
Isn't that all pretty obvious from simply watching the films or moreover listening to Lucas's endless rhetoric.
I still have big problems linking the two Trilogies. They seem like chalk and cheese to me.
The OT was inventive, original (well, traditional with a twist), funny, clever and above all entertaining. The PT for me was trite and derivitive and lacked all that made the OT such a big part of childhood. I really don't think that the PT will grow with it's child audience the way that the OT did with my generation. My newphews have grown up with the PT and have already moved on. They still like the OT but say that the PT is good for their little cousin - aged 4.
I don't think this TV series will do much to help matters either.
JD
I have to agree, to me the saga is like putting a square peg into a round hole it doesnt fit IMO, I can watch the Prequel films if I feel like it but I dont find them as enjoyable and dont have the same replay value as the Original films and I also notice the quality drop from the original films especially Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back.
To be honest, I rarely set through any of the films anymore. Now, I mostly read the books/comics (which I find superior to the films). If it weren't for the EU, Star Wars would be pretty dry, IMHO. And, IMO, all of the films have an equal replay value. I really don't think ANH is any better than, say, TPM.
I have disagree about the replay value, for me anyway, i must have seen the original Star Wars film at least 200+ times and even today sometimes I watch it twice a day and enjoy it immensly, but its a struggle sometimes through thl TPM for me if I felt like watching it