I agree totally. I'm a big supporter of fan edits and preserving out of print titles, however it should only be downloaded if it not available for sale or you own the original. Its the same with music, I own thousands of live bootlegs but would never not buy the official releases. It would be great if there was a way to verify if people owned the real things, but that is probably near impossible.

The great thing about most people in the Star Wars community, is that wether they like Lucas' policy on the originals or not, they support him financially with DVD, Toy, and Ticket sales. I think if the commercial stuff is banned, and the site encourages the sale of the retail dvds aswell, that would be a fair balance.