My problem, which is a problem I'm relying upon Moth3r and zion to help me work out, is balancing the needs of the community with social responsibility. I have no problems with people downloading fan edits--as long as they own the official release in retail form. No way to verify that, however. I also have no problems with people downloading preservation efforts, but what about projects like ocpmovie's, which are a hybrid of an old release and a current retail release? How granular do we need to get with the rules?
I want the preservation forums to thrive, and my fear is that new restrictions will send people running to other places in order to avoid the requirements set forth in the rules.