logo Sign In

Post #174226

Author
Kaal-Jhyy
Parent topic
Lucas and CGI in the Prequels
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/174226/action/topic#174226
Date created
29-Jan-2006, 8:54 PM
Originally posted by: battlewars
somehow stop motion still seems better to me


How can you say that?!?
Ok, you like the "look" and the "feel" of stop motion (and it's the same for me!), but you can't tell that stop-motion is "better" than CGI, sorry (or you have to buy (new?) glasses...).
You know, I love Amiga computers, I feel a great nostalgia for these computers, but I'll never tell you that Amiga is "better" than my actual computer, just cause it would be a lie... My actual computer is far more performant than my old Amiga, and I can do things that I've never been able to do with an Amiga...
That's all, and it's the same for visual effects.

Note: if you're not conviced, go watch the JP documentaries. In one, we can see dino animations done in stop-motion (that was the initial technique choosed for JP). And now, compare with CG scenes in the movie. So, question: which one looks better?...