Originally posted by: Mr Bungle
There is no way ROTJ is inferior to any Prequel film.
*raises her wine glass* Hear! Hear! I agree, good sir.
ROTJ is still wonderful. The PT can't even touch that movie. If there are any inconsistancies, it is because the PT couldn't pull it's head out of it's ass and become a great film trilogy.
It still get goosebumps to this day whenever I watch the final duel between Vader and Luke. It's not fancy, but it doesn't have to be. Luke doesn't need to do a fly-fly-turny-fly-kick to Vader's face and stuff. Luke is caught up in pure rage and is just swinging his saber around trying to kill Vader. The music is what sells that scene and I love it.
Then followed up by the Emperor killing Luke slowly on the throne room floor as Luke cries out in pain, begging his father to do something; anything.
I didn't see anything of that caliber in the PT. Not once.
If anything ROTJ is a BETTER film because of the PT.
There is no way ROTJ is inferior to any Prequel film.
*raises her wine glass* Hear! Hear! I agree, good sir.
ROTJ is still wonderful. The PT can't even touch that movie. If there are any inconsistancies, it is because the PT couldn't pull it's head out of it's ass and become a great film trilogy.
It still get goosebumps to this day whenever I watch the final duel between Vader and Luke. It's not fancy, but it doesn't have to be. Luke doesn't need to do a fly-fly-turny-fly-kick to Vader's face and stuff. Luke is caught up in pure rage and is just swinging his saber around trying to kill Vader. The music is what sells that scene and I love it.
Then followed up by the Emperor killing Luke slowly on the throne room floor as Luke cries out in pain, begging his father to do something; anything.
I didn't see anything of that caliber in the PT. Not once.
If anything ROTJ is a BETTER film because of the PT.
Originally posted by: battlewars
...have you seen rots lately? i got through the first 3 minutes but by the time i got to the buzz droids i quickly lost interest Yesterday (I was bored) I pulled out my ROTS DVD and was watching the first deleted scene with Shak-ti and the dialogue was so bad that I literly screamed out in horror. My aunt came downstairs to see if I was okay. She thought that I had either broke my toe or that I was turning into the Incredible Hulk.
I mean, for god's sake!! Could the dialogue get anymore worse!? Here you have that girl die, rather, blandly, and then you've got Anakin say, "That was a bad." Followed by an even worse line by Obi-Wan, "Mistake."
AURUGHHH!!
"That was a bad." is not a sentance people! Learn some grammar. You need a subject to tie in with that predicate! Aughh! The fact that Obi-Wan then woodenly says "mistake" just makes me cry. Who the hell talks like that?