Indeed, I agree that the trailer was a good start, those images were an incentive to make me want to watch TPM. Could not stop to watch that trailer over and over again. I liked the movie when it came out. It was early morning when I saw it, could not make it for the midnight show. And I enjoy it, of course it is not the original trilogy but what can I say? when it comes to Star Wars, I am not able to be a critic, I let myself be that kid when he saw Empire strikes Back for the first time in a drive at the age of 6 ( Yes, Empire was my first Star Wars movie, weirldy enough, I saw Star Wars (aka New Hope) after a few months I saw Empire. Just to go back to the TPM, The Pod Race and The final duel blew me away.
As for AOTC, the trailer with the Vader breathing blew me away, I was anticipating a lot, I have to admit that the final duel with Yoda and Dooku saved the movie for me. That was my best memory.
ROTS, my girlfriend won tickets for the advenced screening for me, that alone was special, I enjoyed the ROTS a lot, The 2 duels at the end, the space battles, it was all great, of course I let the bad dialog slip I think it is my third favorite star wars movie after Empire and Star Wars. I think I saw it 4 times that same week. I saw it 2 or 3 times on dvd.
Of course it will never beat the original trilogy experience when I grew up ( a good memory I have from the OT is the REVENGE OF THE JEDI teaser lol)