Without being able to read them and I don’t think Paul Duncan has read them. All we rely on is George’s telling of what they were to Paul and to James Cameron.

They are under lock and key at Disney and you would likely have to sign an NDA even if they would let you read them.

If I could read his story treatments would I go that is a cool idea. or wow this is so stupid even Disney did better.

Darth Maul being the big bad and midichlorians are baffling to me as being serious decisions.

Darth Talon belongs in the legacy era. 137 ABY is when Legacy is.

Luke still being in exile is exactly what Disney did, and if the doctrine of no attachment holds, how is he not the same as Last Jedi Luke just different. Niece and Nephew, no children of his own that reflects the prequel. those prequel jedi teachings were flawed. a new jedi order should reject them.