Yeah, all valid points mate.
See? I don’t know how I’m expected to respond to comments that I think just aren’t reflecting what happens in the movies, like that one, other than pointing out how I think it doesn’t reflect the movies:
Where does Obi-Wan lie, beyond a couple things? He only really does about Anakin wanting Luke to have the lightsaber and the Vader killed your dad thing really I think that I remember.
Nothing in the PT movies ever develops the idea that Anakin was seen as a bad pilot in those movies, so I don’t see how that’s a lie. If you wanted to see more of that, I can understand that, but I don’t see it as a contradiction.
To say he was always whining I think isn’t what happens in the movies. And why would never following his lead contradict what he said in OT?
No one in the PT denies Anakin love or companionship. Obi is his friend and straight says that he loved him. The Jedi as a whole show companionship to each other and care I think.
The Jedi as a group, Obi included, didn’t take him from his only family. Shmi wanted him to go and Anakin wanted to as well, and Qui-Gon offered and told him that it would be hard. No taking involved, as far as I think how that term used here implies.
They never told him not to fall in love with a woman in the movies. Attachment was something the Jedi were told not to do, not love.
What am I supposed to do if not disagree and point that out? Not reply at all? Why?