The one I dislike Is Darth Maul alive. I still think he died in the Phantom Menace. Though its hard to see how it could be as bad as Disney’s return of Sidous. Somehow Palpatine returned. I don’t know if It could even enjoy the novelty of it if I wasn’t familiar with Dark Empire and aware how bad an adaption of that comic the film was.

Luke to Rey a Jedi’s weapon deserves more respect. The entire film was a course correction of the Last Jedi. Luke lifts the ship out of the water. Rey learns she is a Sith by birth in her bloodline. Decides to reject her heritage and adopt the Skywalker/ Jedi lineage.

Is the Darth Maul idea of Lucas a Black Sun or a Crimson Dawn kind of thing.

I think the story should have been about Luke being a father. And the legacy of Vader. Of course, I’m not a screenwriter I don’t make those decisions.