Very old thread but because I am at the moment watching some Fan Films:

Knightquest
Broken Allegiance
Darth Maul - Apprentice
The Dark Redemption
Kenobi

Three old and two younger productions in my top 5.
Today the possiblities are quite easier (or better) to create a star wars fan film. Nevertheless Knightquest, Broken Allegiance and The Dark Redemption has the special Star Wars magic 😃
The Darth Maul movie is an optical masterpiece and the Kenobi movie has an awesome casting and acting.