I've honestly only seen episode 1 once and episode 2 twice in their sanctioned versions. I've watched the edits by Magnoliafan once each as well. I don't rewatch them again and again, and as a result, most of my criticism is of small things I remember from the first two and mostly from the third film, which I have watched at least 5 times (I actually enjoy 99% of it).

I honestly cringed a lot more when I watched magnoliafan's edit of Phantom Menace a lot more than when I saw it originally. I actually didn't hate it the first time I saw it, and sort of left it at that by never seeing it again (then again, a GREAT film would've had me coming back for more time and time again).