logo Sign In

Anjohan's The Rings of Power - The Film Cut [FINISHED VERSION] — Page 8

Author
Time

Dang… I’m sorry to hear that you were disappointed with Season 2 and that you’re struggling with it in regards to your second film. I had actually finished the series yesterday and came here to see if you had started work on a second film. lol.

Also, good to see that a finished definitive version of your first film is now released!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

BrotherOfSasquatch said:

Dang… I’m sorry to hear that you were disappointed with Season 2 and that you’re struggling with it in regards to your second film. I had actually finished the series yesterday and came here to see if you had started work on a second film. lol.

Also, good to see that a finished definitive version of your first film is now released!

Well, as much as I dislike a lot of stuff with Rings of Power - the stuff they do well when you remove the fluff is brilliant.

I’m way into the works on my Film II, and I blame my OCD.

WHAT HAVE I DONE?
The Ancient Lore
Kenobi: A Star Wars Story
Harry Potter Revisited
Game of Thrones Film Edits
Titanic Restructured
… and more.

Author
Time

Is it/Future edits of this still on the Google Drive you gave me years ago for your Harry Potter fan edits? Because I also thought I saw you remove the original version of the rings of power edit here?

Author
Time

Is it/Future edits of this still on the Google Drive you gave me years ago for your Harry Potter fan edits? Because I also thought I saw you remove the original version of the rings of power edit here?

Author
Time

Thanks for the movie , this version is much better , chronologically consistent within itslef (hard to make it consistent with canon). Unfortunately I don’t think it could be improved a lot further since content of series is subpar.
Imho , I think a version

  • With Very minimal Galadriel , Gandalf , Arondhir and no hobbits may even be better (what’s left 😛)
  • A short introduction at the start of movie possibly with some AI help about Morgoth ,Valinor , Numenor etc may be nice.

Thanks again for the hard work

Author
Time

Hi! I’d be very interested to see your edit of RoP, if you’re willing to send me a link.

I had created my own edit of Season 1, then cut that edit down a great deal, as I planned to join Seasons 1 and 2 into a single film. Eventually, I stopped working on it because I ran into issues with the editing quality (since I based my second edit off the completed first one) and didn’t have the motivation to start over from scratch. Maybe I’ll pick it up again at some point.

Based on some of what I read, I think we had some similar ideas, though I opted to remove the Harfoot entirely, with the possibility of creating a separate movie if there was enough good material from Season 2—which there really wasn’t. Maybe a “Wizards of Rhûn” film might be better, beginning with Gandalf (it just had to be him) doing his thing in the East and mostly ignoring his story from the first 2 seasons.