logo Sign In

Post #165570

Author
Tim Lehrbach
Parent topic
The "ADigitalMan Special Editions" DVD Info and Feedback Thread (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/165570/action/topic#165570
Date created
26-Dec-2005, 7:00 AM
Watched ADM's ROTS last night, I'll say right off that the dialogue insertion for Qui-Gon in the Yoda meditation scene (Polis Massa) is great....I think it works very well and improves the meaning of that scene, and Yoda explaining Qui-Gon to Kenobi later on.

I'm not really of fan of the deleted scenes, I think it tends to bog down the flow of the story in some cases, but the interesting one was Yoda landing on dagobah, I liked the part inserted with "are you ready?....yes." and "MTFBWY master".

I would have left out "will he finish what he begins?" and "finding him was the will of the force" because I found them too recognizable from ESB and TPM.

Again this is why I love seeing other peoples edits, there are always great ideas in these things that you never think of when doing your in own edit.

BTW I did a very similar edit in the Palpatine/ Anakin opera scene....replacing Midichlorians with Force, and using a repeated shot from behind them to cover up Palps wording Midichlorians.