Everything I said was in the context of the second clip which is for ANH. Therefore I stand by everything I said. The ROTJ video looks pretty good, it was actually recommended to me a few days ago if you can believe it. I was just “criticizing” (which btw this is a forum not an echo chamber) the first video.

Gotta lead with that next time.

But also I’m providing my context, which is different roles and people can tackle different tasks, clearly color was off but that dive down shot of the formation split of the Y wings and X wings and the sun in the background… pretty sick stuff. You know you pick the good stuff, not tear the whole thing apart. (though you get credit for specifying color standpoint, which btw I never thought the color was great either, but I thought that kind of went without saying… but I guess I have to be extremely punctual and concise with my prefacing)
Have Ady mask some stuff off adjust the color and contrast, boom. off to next thing in the pipeline. I stand by what I said.

I can believe someone recommended it to you, cause you know, its pretty solid. Came up in my algo. Anyways just trying to help this Andreas fellow and Ady. I’ll just sit back now