Hal - I’ve got a few pieces of feedback before you re-render the 1080p large version to fix those issues. It seems like a couple things slipped through the cracks that weren’t on your changelog:
- Somehow the goofy sentence you trimmed when Jar Jar is accepting his temporary position from Padme got reinstated, along with Anakin complaining about Obi-Wan to Padme. I’m actually fine with the latter part being reinstated, because it means you could potentially cut out the cringey part about Anakin making Padme feel uncomfortable without the scene feeling too short, now.
- Somehow the part where Mace Windu and Yoda in the Senate telegraph to the audience their exact next moves got reinstated, as well. I really enjoyed how their arrival to Geonosis was made into a surprise later on - it really escalated the stakes for the trio in the arena.
- I highly recommend checking out the trim JoyOfEditing made to the droid factory scene to remove Anakin’s lightsaber getting caught on his cloak. This sticks out really badly.
- The audience member I watched it with was really disappointed to not see the extended dismemberment of Jango instated 😉 (he pointed this out without me saying anything at all about it previously)
That was about it! Thanks for making this for us.