logo Sign In

Post #1646661

Author
coreyatad
Parent topic
ANDOR: The Rogue One Arc (Rogue One Rescore) [AVAILABLE]
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1646661/action/topic#1646661
Date created
14-May-2025, 2:53 AM

Posted this over on fanedit.org, but figured since there’s more activity on this forum, I’d post here, too.

Just finished Andor, and decided to immediately follow it up with your incredible fan edit. It plays extremely well, really like a continuation. Really, just marvellous work.

Though I do have maybe one note off the top. It’s funny, because the way you have it is how it was originally, but I think given how Andor plays out, his going from confirming the intelligence on Kafrene to finding Jyn just feels a bit fast. I wonder if it might make sense to start Episode 13 with Cassian’s introduction. Then Bodhi. Then maybe cut to Jyn in prison/being transported, with the flashback slotted in there, maybe slightly chopped up. I think that might smooth out the pacing a bit at the start, and would also kind of fit better with the established use of interspersed flashbacks in the first arc of Andor season 1, as well as season 2 episode 10. Might also make it feel more like the story is being handed over from Cassian to Jyn. Of course, all this might just be me. And perhaps it’s too complicated to bother with anyway.

I’ll also second Onhisbacko on adding in that new Star Wars logo at the start (along with a previously on for episode 13, of course). Could also make sense to copy the format of season 2’s BBY title cards over black and have it go BBY0 in blue letters over black instead of how it is in the movie.