logo Sign In

Post #1622701

Author
MiDKnighT
Parent topic
Working on a PT Remix of Spence, Anti-Cheese, and Hal Edits
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1622701/action/topic#1622701
Date created
3-Jan-2025, 4:17 PM

revel911 said:

  1. A perfect edit for the prequels (at least for me) would include changing out the alien audio to something that needed subtitles. This way you can control the dialogue and remove some of the terrible accents. Maybe using one of the foreign languages, ran through some effects?

Yes the Gungans and the Neimoidians all have alien voice and subtitles in the TPM edit I’m working on. Haven’t looked at the other two prequels yet for that.

  1. The Anakin vs Obiwan fight has a few shots that just go too long or feel far too far fetched, would be great to trim those so the flow matches the series better and the pace.

Have you seen Spence’s edit of this? I like it a lot. Probably just going to keep that one as a base.

I had a reviewer give feedback on parts of the TPM edit so far. He didn’t really like Jar Jar’s voice from the “anti-cheese” edits. You can hear what the anti-cheese Jar Jar sounds like here:
https://youtu.be/IXPUCh6M_pg?si=lHI5EnLfCPq21U1I&t=131

If I switch it - do any of these potential Jar Jar voices work?

https://jumpshare.com/s/HM9w06RDKsAGdJZeApAw

Which Jar Jar voice works the best? If any? Or I could build off / change one of those. Or if anybody knows of a good text-to-speech A.I. voice that would work let me know.