logo Sign In

The Unpopular Expanded Universe Opinions Thread — Page 3

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I don’t blame Filoni for the discrepancies between The Clone Wars and the Clone Wars Multimedia Project. However, I do think spending too much time around George Lucas may have negatively influenced him.

At first, Filoni wanted to tell a completely different story, centered on an original cast of characters who’d go on adventures at the edges of the galaxy, far from major figures like Anakin and Obi-Wan. He didn’t want to heavily involve the main characters because, in the beginning, he cared about continuity and wanted to avoid contradicting the Republic comics and other materials from the Multimedia Project. But George Lucas wasn’t fond of that idea and pushed for the series to focus on the film’s main characters, which inevitably led to contradictions with previously published material. So I don’t blame Filoni for these inconsistencies, because he genuinely tried at first to create something new while respecting the existing canon.

That said, I’m convinced that over time, being so close to George Lucas changed the way he looked at the franchise. While he initially seemed interested in preserving continuity and avoiding major contradictions, spending so much time with someone who famously said “continuity is for wimps” must’ve shifted his perspective. It turned him into someone who, much like his mentor, doesn’t care much about consistency within the universe, which explains his disregard for previously established continuity (whether it’s Legends or Canon) in later years.

“I know that all of you like to dream about space and are a little bit of envious of us. But you know what? We’re also envious of you. We are exploring space, but it’s only the beginning. Planets and unknown worlds are awaiting you. You will continue to storm the Universe.”

— Yuri Gagarin

Author
Time

Clone Wars isn’t a part of EU though it contradicts EU and the lore and canon established. The Genddy series fits in EU. Filoni does not. They could do all the edits they wanted to try to bring Filoni into EU before it was moved to legends and they never worked. I always despised the Mortis arc in EU. It made Crucible a novel not worth reading.

As to whether they never brought Hayden in to dub Anakin in the cartoons I have no idea why? I do enjoy Matt Lanter so much more than Hayden it’s another level. But Hayden was so good in the new shows. Why didn’t that show in the prequel. Except in some places, it’s like George had him read his lines with as little emotion as possible flat and bored.