logo Sign In

Post #161877

Author
MTHaslett
Parent topic
The legendary "Starkiller Ranch" Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/161877/action/topic#161877
Date created
8-Dec-2005, 5:29 PM
THX: To be honest the whole Qui-Gon discovers the secret of immortality sub-plot isn't too hot. It would be better just to cut it than run rings trying to explain it. (Aah, that's more like it, THX).

***

Lol!

To be fair, I know a lot of fans had real gripes about the "disappearing Jedi" rules. But I was never one of them. I'd be for cutting the reference too if I thought we could get everyone on board.


---

THX: But I do feel that Qui-Gon, sensing he might fail, prepared for the other side in advance, while Maul was held back by the red force-field. It wasn't explicit and could be interpreted in many ways but it was reminiscent of Ben's calm before he disappeared in ANH.

***

We haven't gotten to the real "bible" version of Episode I yet, but I'm hoping to exploit that "meditation moment" to establish a link between Qui Gonn and Anakin -- he's reaching out to Anakin there and trying to help the "chosen one" as he battles Maul. He's collecting himself and conserving energy -- not preparing to lose. The big difference between this and Obi Wan's death is Obi Wan had a practical purpose for letting himself be cut down. I think you're suggesting that Qui Gonn is somehow snatching a small victory from the mouth of defeat -- a defeat that was by no means certain since Obi Wan shortly dispatches Maul all by himself.