logo Sign In

Post #161750

Author
twister111
Parent topic
The Star Wars Saga - From a newcomer's point of view
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/161750/action/topic#161750
Date created
8-Dec-2005, 3:44 AM
Hm, if the poster who posted that actually did that. From a scientific point of view his test is null and, void. To come to a valid conclusion he would have to get at least 3 more participants. Also, he would have to show the original tester the original trilogy to see what her oppions of them are. Especially since she mentions the pacing is slow in the original trilogy but, she was watching the DVD editions. Therefore, she was watching the versions with more stuff added in. Thus, the pacing is slower. Who knows Empire might become her favorite if she saw the original version. Plus, the original versions of the prequels. Then, he would have to show the second participant the Original trilogy(sans Special edition) then the Prequel trilogy(sans Special editions). Then, show another person the Prequel trilogy(sans Special edition) with the Original trilogy(sans Special edition). Then show another person the prequel trilogy with the Original trilogy(sans Special edition). Then, compile thier reactions to reach a semi-clear consensus of how the saga should be shown. From my point of view the saga should be shown to newcomers in it's original version(all the movies with no general order).