didn’t make Vader look A fool like he did in revenge of the Sith
Vader…
- Doesn’t put out the fire separating him and Obi-Wan with the Force, like he just did 30 seconds ago, Force grab Obi-Wan and pull him over, or just walk through the fire. Yes, his suit is that durable, especially in the Canon comics
- Doesn’t arrest the Organa’s for being obvious Jedi sympathizers. There’s no other way Obi-Wan could’ve known about Leia’s capture as it wasn’t public
- Doesn’t order the Star Destroyer pursuing the rebels to use TIE fighters, and redirects the entire Destroyer to follow Obi-Wan’s ship, only to then leave in his own shuttle to face him. All he had to do was order the Destroyer to continue following the rebels and use his shuttle to face Obi-Wan
All of which he would’ve done if he was written in-character with the OT and Canon Vader comics (which are a far better depiction of a younger Vader).
Other out-of-character things, though not necessarily relating to his intelligence:
- The Emperor says Vader lost his duel with Obi-Wan because “Perhaps your feelings for your former master have left you weakened.” But Vader shouldn’t be conflicted when fighting Obi-Wan. Part of his characterization is that he is too utterly consumed by his hatred of his past self and (almost) everything and everyone from that life. His heart should be like a Sun fighting Obi-Wan. Luke was an exception because he represented the future.
- Darth Vader, in Canon material like the comics, is an unrelenting combatant. You can cut off a limb, destroy his respirator, he’ll still fight and win, fueled by the power of the dark side.
When the first Jedi he faces in the suit takes advantage of his cybernetic leg breaking (having thrown a bunch of obstacles his way before the fight) and throws him off a cliff, what happens? Vader painfully bends his body back into shape and uses a droid’s parts to help reconstruct the parts of his suit he needs, and comes back to finish the job. This is not only just one example, but also takes place days after his immolation and surgery.
At this point in his life, nothing but a literal force of nature (flood, earthquake, etc.) would’ve been able to stop Vader killing Obi-Wan, which is why, perhaps, they shouldn’t have fought in the show. - He didn’t kill Reva the second she showed up as a potential inquisitor due to her knowing his identity. That’s kinda one of Vader’s things. He can’t stand anybody knowing his former identity. Nobody can know that he’s human, in any way vulnerable. They must know him as this seemingly invincible monster. It’s an ego thing.
- I loathe how they had Vader “earn” his classic theme. Once he’s in the suit, he’s fully Vader, that’s it. Not “50% Vader” as Chow says.
His hatred of Obi-Wan is not Anakin, it’s Vader. Vader is the pure manifestation of the dark side of Anakin, that’s the whole point. Everything about him is a twisted, evil version of his former self.
Vader was never just this one-dimensional robot that doesn’t give a shit about anything other than following his master’s order. Even in the OT, while he’s mostly incredibly cold, you see that rage, pride, and possessiveness. It’s part of what makes Vader such a compelling, terrifying, and intimidating villain. He has drive, personal stake. His desire for revenge against Kenobi is in ANH. Palpatine should be encouraging his hatred of his former master unless it actually gets in the way of the needs of the Galactic Empire.
Also, what a way to spit on Soule’s 2017 Vader comic run. I am also so beyond sick of the “long game origin/earning the mantle” trope for classic characters in modern media. It’s hack, soulless, uncreative writing.
There are some scenes I actually really like. Terrorizing the villagers, some aspects of the first duel, portraying him as a horror villain, Force pulling the entire ship down, absolutely schooling Reva by beating her without even pulling out his own lightsaber. The scene where Vader admits that he is responsible for his own fall, not Obi-Wan, is almost good if not for the way it ends (with Obi-Wan just walking away and Vader not pursuing further). Vader does, and should, know and embrace that he’s a monster, his regret and self-loathing deeply repressed.
I love the look of the suit and some of his dialogue. Seeing Vader on the bridge of an Imperial Star Destroyer again gave me a nice nostalgic serotonin hit, and his fortress on Mustafar is always cool. I like the added throne, great character development through imagery there. There’s a lot of gorgeous shots of him useful for edits and are just pretty to look at.
In the end, though, it’s hard for me to articulate how frustrating watching what could be potentially amazing content, only for it to drop the ball through. It’d be like if, after the iconic scene in Empire Strikes Back where Vader says one of his coldest lines to Lando, “I am altering the deal. Pray I don’t alter it any further”, as he’s walking off, he then slips on a banana peel and a laugh track plays.
That’s how I feel watching a decent chunk of this show. Just the utter void of seeing all of the parts for a masterpiece only to see it fall apart right in front of my face.
nor did he look like an overly obsessive weirdo like he did in attack of the clones.
…well yeah, there’s no romance subplot. I guess you can say he’s obsessed with Obi-Wan in a different way, but he’s not weird about it, and it’s in-character.
does anyone here think Kenobi is a better prequel than the actual prequel trilogy?
Doesn’t matter Uncle Ben, the 2017 Canon Vader comics are better then both (meme template, if you don’t know look it up).