logo Sign In

Post #1605366

Author
Anjohan
Parent topic
HARRY POTTER: Revisited [Updates and Info]
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1605366/action/topic#1605366
Date created
27-Aug-2024, 3:25 PM

vranir said:

Thank you so much for continuing this very long project!

One question based on an initial skim though: is the volume range the same for all of these? It sounds to me like Order of the Phoenix is significantly louder at all times than Sorcerer’s Stone (not sure about the others).

I tried to play the two of them right after the other on my home cinema system, and couldn’t hear much difference, except that the dialogue is a little bit lower on SS perhaps.

JEDT: A google search revealed to me that many have complained on Reddit that Sorcerer’s Stone and CoS have worse audio than the rest in the series, and many complain about the dialogue. Now, for me, when I go through my audiomixes I focus a lot on audio and have certain filters applied to make them loud and crisp. However, that’s not to say that the main differences would still be there. So yes, OotP and SS might be a tad different in overall audio level quality. Now that I am aware of this, perhaps I will lower OotP on a re-render in the future with about 5-10% or vice versa. I need to listen to them back to back and see if it’s actually necessary as well. I mean, the volume button is a wonderful thing, but then again - as the perfectionist I’m trying to be, I’d love for it to be as balanced as possible.

Thank you for pointing it out, Vranir ❤️ (By the way, I’m halfway through your Rings of Power edit and loving the cuts and pace thus far).