logo Sign In

Post #159979

Author
Klingon_Jedi
Parent topic
Reasons to hate the Special Editions
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/159979/action/topic#159979
Date created
2-Dec-2005, 4:21 AM
Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
From a certain point of view.


No really, it makes a lot more sense to tailor films that, at the time, hadn't been made, than changing 20 year old movies for what amounts to absolutely no reason. There was no reason to change Fett's voice when you can chalk it up to a simple voice changer(like Boba wan't people to think he's another clone). There's no reason for Hayden's head when Anakin is 20 years older. There's no reason to change a perfectly good dialogue just so you can name drop.

The O-OT fits with the prequels just as well as the SSE, without any of the crap either.

Little things could be changed in the PT and it would mesh perfectly without touching the older films.

You're basically saying it would be ok for Empire to say Luke died at Yavin if Lucas so felt like it. Changing an older film to fit a non-existent one just because you're too lazy to make it fit on it's own shouldn't even be an option.