I've heard the argument that I'm using my old expectations of the OT to compare the prequels with, so I've set my self up to be dissapointed, which is complete bullshit. I enjoy movies from all generations, and don't judge films based on if they are black & white, have outdated special effects or outdated acting or if it has 5.1 THX stereo surround or not, I can recognize weither a film I watch is enjoyable, has a good story and acting and overall is of good quality or not...I can say without hesitation, the prequels lack all the essential qualities the OT had, other than effects/technology, they just don't have the quality depth of story, enjoyable characters or imaginative dialogue including humor. It all just comes off as forced creativeness.
Lucas is a great storyteller, but I think since and partially during ROTJ he's lost touch with alot of essential qualities, which made his other films so classic.
And If anyone was wondering, I was 6 when I saw ANH for the first time.