logo Sign In

Post #158123

Author
JennyS1138
Parent topic
If the Prequels had been made first would they have succeeded?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/158123/action/topic#158123
Date created
26-Nov-2005, 11:05 AM
I honestly don't think they would have made even half of what they did had the prequels been made first. Obviously the fans who saw the prequels first would disagree with this, however, however I wonder how many of these new fans would have discovered the prequels without the monsterous ad campaign that could not have existed without the success of the original trilogy.

Basically, I don't think George would have gotten away with making a film like Phantom Menace if it had been the first SW film. Imagine also, if he had made Menace back in 1977 with the same script, a different cast and 1977 effects. I think it would have been the turkey many predicted Star Wars (A New Hope) would be. Could you imagine going into the theatre in 1977 and having a dude in a Jar Jar costume, no pod race, a less impressive lightsaber fight and a very complicated plot dealing with trade disputes, senate meetings and midichlorians?

It's just kind of ironic that many prequel fans not only dislike the OT, but seem to have no respect for the films, especially for the original SW which they find boring, slow and old looking. I wonder how many of them realize that without the OT, the prequels never ever would have been made.