I think we can all win here. We just need to play nice together.

I don’t have the editing skills to see the other collaborative idea to fruition. But I can certainly supply the lines to make all this possible. There would be three edits all based on Ascendant, although certainly not all of them need to be hosted by Hal (unless he’s cool with that). I would only need the smaller 1080p version, too.

Rey Palpatine (original)
Rey Chosen One (preserves TLJ’s reveals but Rey is still special)
Rey Nopatine (Palpatine lies, still a scavenger from nowhere)