I see, I caught up with like 10 pages from this thread and I saw this idea spring from discussion of ‘nobody cut’ ideas, so I was just giving my own thoughts as to why I don’t think it works in making Rey a ‘nobody’ in any meaningful way. It does make more sense as a change that just alters the nature of ‘Rey Palpatine’, though I still think trying to reconcile Rey Palpatine with the revelations from TLJ is an impossible task, might as well just bite the bullet & don’t dwell too much on the logistics of it all, the more you try to explain it the less sense it makes.