logo Sign In

Post #1568249

Author
Octorox
Parent topic
Spence's PT Edits Round 3 (V2 of AOTC Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1568249/action/topic#1568249
Date created
8-Dec-2023, 3:21 PM

Watched the AOTC workprint. In short, it’s a triumph, I think you’ve made the best version of AOTC out there from a narrative and pacing perspective. I was a little skeptical of the decision to remove the asteroid dogfight, but it absolutely makes sense looking at the flow of the edit as a whole. The addition of the training scene from Kenobi works wondering from a narrative perspective, nicely foreshadowing Anakin’s downfall the Dooku fight. While it doesn’t totally match up stylistically, I find it no more jarring the the inclusion of the deleted scenes, many of which have unfinished VFX and have long been a staple of prequel edits.

My only quibble is while The 3PO removal is seamless, it unfortunately makes the edit incompatible with other versions of The Phantom Menace. Just something I will have to live with, I guess.

Very excited to check out ROTS!