Originally posted by: Yoda Is Your Father
2004 emperor looks like a turtle, and neither looks nor sounds anything like the ROTJ Emperor, who is clearly the best. I don't know who they hired to do the Make up on Sith and the 2004 ESB, but they must have been smoking crack, and sharing it with Ian, causing him to forget how to act. Just like I cannot see the CGI Yoda and the puppet Yoda as the same character, I cannot reconcile the 2004 or Sith Emperor with the ROTJ Emperor. I try, but I can't.
2004 emperor looks like a turtle, and neither looks nor sounds anything like the ROTJ Emperor, who is clearly the best. I don't know who they hired to do the Make up on Sith and the 2004 ESB, but they must have been smoking crack, and sharing it with Ian, causing him to forget how to act. Just like I cannot see the CGI Yoda and the puppet Yoda as the same character, I cannot reconcile the 2004 or Sith Emperor with the ROTJ Emperor. I try, but I can't.
I agree. The first time I saw this I thought that the emperor looks nothing like he does in ROTJ. I can even forgive his looking really different in ROTS, because it is over 20-25 years later that we see him again, but not in ESB. The dialouge I don't mind too much, but I have too much of a hard time getting past the crummy makeup.