Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
Padme has exactly the same importance as Anakin, Luke, Leia. I don't get why everyone wants to move away her story from the movies. They give them more depth. And, as for the holiday special, that's exactly reason I'm as obsessed with it as I am.
Originally posted by: theredbaron
Am I the only one who DIDN'T like the Padme's parents house scene? It was completely extraneous. I, for one, don't care enough for Padme's character to even want to know what her parents and house looks like, which is really the only purpose that scene serves. Any important knowledge of her family (which there is none) could have simply been disclosed in the dialogue. It serves no romantic purpose, either, it's just a boring tour of a Naboo-ian house. In fact, this kind of approach reminds me of the Holiday Special - a day in the life of a Wookie family.
Yep, not a fan. Glad Lucas left it out.
Originally posted by: Adamwankenobi
Myself, I seriously would want the rebellion scenes back into ROTS. He is a fool for not adding them in. They tie together the plot elements VERY well. AOTC needs the Padme's parents house scenes back in as well.
Myself, I seriously would want the rebellion scenes back into ROTS. He is a fool for not adding them in. They tie together the plot elements VERY well. AOTC needs the Padme's parents house scenes back in as well.
Am I the only one who DIDN'T like the Padme's parents house scene? It was completely extraneous. I, for one, don't care enough for Padme's character to even want to know what her parents and house looks like, which is really the only purpose that scene serves. Any important knowledge of her family (which there is none) could have simply been disclosed in the dialogue. It serves no romantic purpose, either, it's just a boring tour of a Naboo-ian house. In fact, this kind of approach reminds me of the Holiday Special - a day in the life of a Wookie family.
Yep, not a fan. Glad Lucas left it out.
Padme has exactly the same importance as Anakin, Luke, Leia. I don't get why everyone wants to move away her story from the movies. They give them more depth. And, as for the holiday special, that's exactly reason I'm as obsessed with it as I am.
Ahhh, no. Perhaps if Lucas was *successful* in portraying his characters with any kind of depth, and if the actors could act (okay, I'll cut Ewen, Liam, and Ian some slack), then *MAYBE* I would care. But the fact is, we didn't get a tour of Han's house, Leia's house, yada yada yada. We saw Luke's house with his Aunt and Uncle, and Obi-wan's hovel, but guess what? It was actually important to the plot.