- Time
- Post link
May I get a link please?
- Time
- Post link
If you can comfortably handwave something yourself, it’s not an error.
Star Wars Rebels Recut - A Fanedit TV Series — Page 3
- Time
- Post link
PMs Sent 😃
- Time
- Post link
Is there a way to fix the continuity errors caused but the final clone wars season and the first episode of the bad batch. Kanan saying the clones said didn’t mean to turn on the Jedi. saying it was the chips that made them do it and Rex and the other clones saying they removed their chips and never turned on their Jedi.
I don’t see this as a continuity error. I mean technically speaking Rex didn’t turn on his Jedi. Ashoka was not a Jedi and Anakin had turned to the darkside at this time and although he did turn, he was saved by Ashoka and assisted in her survival.
As for the Wolf and Gregor, I’m not sure what they did. (feel free to prove me wrong here! I’m always opening to editing further!)
- Time
- Post link
Is there a way to fix the continuity errors caused but the final clone wars season and the first episode of the bad batch. Kanan saying the clones said didn’t mean to turn on the Jedi. saying it was the chips that made them do it and Rex and the other clones saying they removed their chips and never turned on their Jedi.
I don’t see this as a continuity error. I mean technically speaking Rex didn’t turn on his Jedi. Ashoka was not a Jedi and Anakin had turned to the darkside at this time and although he did turn, he was saved by Ashoka and assisted in her survival.
As for the Wolf and Gregor, I’m not sure what they did. (feel free to prove me wrong here! I’m always opening to editing further!)
Wolf and Gregor removing their chips was never shown. Kanan saying the clones mentioned the chip after attacking him was also never shown.
- Time
- Post link
So far this edit works very well. I have one suggestion though, how about implementing credits like Eddie does with his TCW restructured series, seeing the Ralph Mcquiarie paintings at the end of each episode would be nice.
Also the original episode titles are at the end of the episodes where you’ve changed to a new title, so I think they should be taken out.
- Time
- Post link
May I get a link please?
Really looking forward to checking out this edit!
- Time
- Post link
So far this edit works very well. I have one suggestion though, how about implementing credits like Eddie does with his TCW restructured series, seeing the Ralph Mcquiarie paintings at the end of each episode would be nice.
Also the original episode titles are at the end of the episodes where you’ve changed to a new title, so I think they should be taken out.
I do really like this idea yoshif8tures! I’ll do some further thinking on this. I might implement this after I’ve completed my V2 edit for season 2. My Main focus is on the core experience of the show after that I might add more polishing ideas such as this! 😄
- Time
- Post link
May I get a link please?
Really looking forward to checking out this edit!
PM Sent 😃
- Time
- Post link
Is there a way to fix the continuity errors caused but the final clone wars season and the first episode of the bad batch. Kanan saying the clones said didn’t mean to turn on the Jedi. saying it was the chips that made them do it and Rex and the other clones saying they removed their chips and never turned on their Jedi.
I don’t see this as a continuity error. I mean technically speaking Rex didn’t turn on his Jedi. Ashoka was not a Jedi and Anakin had turned to the darkside at this time and although he did turn, he was saved by Ashoka and assisted in her survival.
As for the Wolf and Gregor, I’m not sure what they did. (feel free to prove me wrong here! I’m always opening to editing further!)
Wolf and Gregor removing their chips was never shown. Kanan saying the clones mentioned the chip after attacking him was also never shown.
I understand it wasn’t shown however that doesn’t make it non-cannon in my eyes. At this stage, I feel the scene deepens the lore and emotional weight of the episode. To my knowledge it doesn’t directly contradict anything we’ve seen so far. For that reason I will keep it in for now 😃 Thank you for your suggestion! 😃 I do appreciate community input and requests.
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
Double post
- Time
- Post link
So far this edit works very well. I have one suggestion though, how about implementing credits like Eddie does with his TCW restructured series, seeing the Ralph Mcquiarie paintings at the end of each episode would be nice.
Also the original episode titles are at the end of the episodes where you’ve changed to a new title, so I think they should be taken out.I do really like this idea yoshif8tures! I’ll do some further thinking on this. I might implement this after I’ve completed my V2 edit for season 2. My Main focus is on the core experience of the show after that I might add more polishing ideas such as this! 😄
Sounds great! I was really impressed with Eddie and how he changed the feel of the series by changing the opening and closing titles, it also really firmly stamps your own name onto it as well. May I suggest a version of the rebellion theme? I am sure there are good versions on youtube. I believe theres an art book for the show too, or you could do the same with eddie and convert certain scenes from the show into an art piece that works well too
- Time
- Post link
I haven’t told anyone this yet, and nobody’s mentioned it, but when I couldnt’ find real concept art… I cheated 😉
- Time
- Post link
I haven’t told anyone this yet, and nobody’s mentioned it, but when I couldnt’ find real concept art… I cheated 😉
I noticed, but you still did a good job 😅
- Time
- Post link
I haven’t told anyone this yet, and nobody’s mentioned it, but when I couldnt’ find real concept art… I cheated 😉
It’s not cheating when it looks great and feels authentic 😉 hahaha! That’s just good editing!
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
A New version of S01E01 is uploading. I’ll update the main post when it’s available for download. I’d love to know what people think! It’s the beginning of my V3 edits which have updated introductions, further polished edits, changes and new fancy credits inspired by EddieDean’s work with the Clone Wars Refocused as requested by Yoshiif8tures.
As I go through the V3 edits I’ll be updating the main post with the original episodes used and any other noteworthy changes. I’m aiming for V3 to be my final version! (pending any and all feedback).
I’ll be getting back into the swing of editing now that my University year is ending and hopefully I get a good chunk done (namely season 2) before my first child is born haha!
- Time
- Post link
Nice work so far, but I’d say you need a bit more text in the opening. I’ll think about something and respond again later.
I think that it should then directly open to the Rebels logo should come directly after that, without the annoying music that accompanies it.
Also your text is too large for both credits.
I also think the ending music should be changed to something more rebels specific like with Eddie did with his series.
- Time
- Post link
Nice work so far, but I’d say you need a bit more text in the opening. I’ll think about something and respond again later.
I think that it should then directly open to the Rebels logo should come directly after that, without the annoying music that accompanies it.
Also your text is too large for both credits.
I also think the ending music should be changed to something more rebels specific like with Eddie did with his series.
Thanks for the feedback! I’ll play around with the text size
Did you have any music in mind. Honestly that was the choice I struggled with the most so far.
I’ll have a play around with more text and explore your opening suggestions! 😃
- Time
- Post link
I’ve already improved the opening with more text (great suggestion) and the text is already looking better smaller I’ll upload a V3.1 for S01E01 at some stage (and possibly a V3.2 after further feedback) but for now I’ll await potential suggestions for credit music.
- Time
- Post link
How about this theme from https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0kn1vSxKtsg Jedi fallen order?
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
How about this theme from https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0kn1vSxKtsg Jedi fallen order?
I think that works much better and thematically the purpose of the theme fits. Although it’s Cal’s theme, it could symbolize Jedi in the time of the Empire. I’ll be changing the end credits to this. Fits way better then my choice. Thanks Yoshif8tures! I’d love to hear your opinions on the new version! 😃 (once its uploaded)
- Time
- (Edited)
- Post link
.
- Time
- Post link
Could you just upload the end and post credits as different samples to see how they work, it would be quicker that reuploading the episodes again.
- Time
- Post link
Could you just upload the end and post credits as different samples to see how they work, it would be quicker that reuploading the episodes again.
I did think of that… but I’ve uploaded 3.1 now already hahaha. If I make further changes I’ll do it like that! 😄
- Time
- Post link
it’s an improvement but I still think you need to remove the ear sore that is the rebels music when the logo pops out, much like Eddie did with his series.
How about trying to use the same music as he did and see do it works? I like how he times the epic music perfectly for when the clone wars logo pops and it gives me chills