logo Sign In

Post #1507082

Author
of_Kaiburr_and_Whills
Parent topic
Prequel Nostalgia
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1507082/action/topic#1507082
Date created
9-Oct-2022, 9:53 PM

Darth Malgus said:

Yeah, it’s a strange phenomenon. A few years ago, it seemed like prequel fans used to be more laid back and more open to criticism of the movies. They used to be more willing to laugh alongside you at the prequels’ ridiculous moments. But as time has gone on, the prequel fandom has gotten more and more fervent and unironic and sensitive to criticism, which is a shame. Now you have all these video essays about how the prequels are masterpieces and how the flaws aren’t actually flaws.

I don’t want to start an unnecessary controversy, but I want to give my opinion on this topic, since I’m a Prequel fan.
I’m one of those people who’s not bothered by the things that annoy everyone. For example, the dialogue and the love story don’t bother me, as well as Jar Jar. So, I personally don’t see these things as flaws. However, I think it’s wrong to say that the Prequels have no flaws in general. But I think that the people who say that the Prequels have no flaws are driven to do so because, on the other side, there are people who say that they have ONLY flaws. That is, people of one extreme act the way they act because on the other side there are people of the other extreme. Since there are people who say that the Prequels have ONLY flaws, then there are people who, as an automatic reaction, defend everything about the movies and say they have NO flaws. The fact that there are no Original Trilogy fans who defend everything about the movies, is explained simply by the fact that there are no people who say that the Originals have only flaws, unlike the Prequels.

I agree with this.

What I’m about to say may not be the perfect analogy to describe it, but I’ll try anyway: Its like a pendulum swing. For so long discourse over the prequels was held in such a critical regard that its completely swung in the other direction, especially as those of us who grew up with them can now respond to those critiques.