^^^ Right on. Admittedly, this guy’s version presents and feels more like a “director’s extended cut” of a movie - and that’s what I appreciate about it. Pretty much my only (or biggest) personal requirement of a fan-edit is that it doesn’t transform the material into something that it never was -or- was never meant to be. At the end of the day, the source material IS canon (for better or for worse) and I prefer to consume my media as canonically as possible (-even if some of it subjectively sucks).

I agree completely with Docking Bay here. I approached the last jedi the same way with Poppasketti’s edit, that way I can actually consider them canon without have much if any dispute with those that have just seen the theater version. I kinda view the TikTok version as an almost jumping off place for others to make edits from yanno. I’m even considering using it to make my own edit with his as a base but including all the best ideas from all those far more talented then myself.

Also Damn! scottkin That reddit editing is amazing thats exactly what I’m talking about! I feel like Grievous over here adding things to my collection! LOL