My overall investment in current Star Wars is low enough that I don’t get in my feelings about it, but I can’t help but think that this show is one of those major missteps that will be mourned by fans in the future. When Disney bought the rights, one of the earliest and most common requests was ‘bring back Ewan as Obi-Wan’. He is a great actor and a great pick for that role, something that practically everyone agrees on regardless of their thoughts on the PT. It was a tremendous waste to have him return for this show, an opportunity that will forever be squandered.
It’s like how some fans feel about the original cast in the ST, though I would argue that at least in that situation there was advancing age as a factor which limited what could be done.