In my opinion both are crap its which is the lesser of two evils,in the Holiday Special at least you have Han,Luke Leia and Chewie etc, I lasted about the whole duration,ut some of it does make you wish you were watching the great Jar Jar Binks himself and all of the fart and poop jokes that go with him, but I would have go for Menace anyday at least it has a little more relevance to the Classics and has more redeeming features.