CGI, for all its worth, just doesn't seem to "fit" (at least not yet) as realistically and naturally with humans as do puppets. Am I crazy or have you noticed this? Another BIG problem is that GL is not quite the best director in the world.... I'll admit that Mark Hamill may not be the best actor in the world either, but he sure had chemistry with Fisher/Ford/etc., while better-known actors in the PT just plain suck. Please take the time to REALLY watch the "romantic-yet-tragic" dialogue by the fire between Amidala and Anakin in AOTC, and please tell me that I'm not the only one to find REALLY bad acting there!