logo Sign In

Post #149046

Author
The Bizzle
Parent topic
Will GL start a trend of other classic films being changed?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/149046/action/topic#149046
Date created
19-Oct-2005, 2:17 PM
You don't pay too much attention to film and film history if you think this is a "trend" much less one started by Lucas.

There's a reason the imdb has an "alternate version" feature as part of their standard menu. Other directors, writers, musicians have made a habit of revisiting their works PLENTY of time. Not just hacks, or cheapo burnouts like Sharon Osbourne. People like BEETHOVEN, or TOLKIEN, Da VINCI, even. To think this is a Lucas innovation is ridiculously shortsighted. Sure, it's fun to create a bunch of "The sky is falling" scenarios just for shits n' giggles, but that's about all this is good for--artistic revisions are not a Lucas innovation, nor did he really popularize it. If anything, he DEMONIZED it

This isn't a trend. This is just how art has gone over the years. It's just as malleable now as it was then. The difference is that we didn't have the internet then.