logo Sign In

Post #1489959

Author
FrederikOlsen
Parent topic
The Kenobi Movie Show (Spoilers)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1489959/action/topic#1489959
Date created
23-Jun-2022, 4:47 AM

MalaStrana#2 said:

FrederikOlsen said:

You didn’t even counter my argument

Because you don’t provide any substance to anything. You just read the issues regarding continuity without noticing all the rest. You should read the film crit hulk paper as he is way better than me to address the overall issues with this show and with current Star Wars.

On my side I won’t lose time arguing about the show inner consistencies with fans creating their own patches of what the writers of the show didn’t think about making clear and square.

You know, ANH is a very clear and simple movie. This clarity took a hell of time and talent. Something this show is just millions of miles away at every single level. You can like it I don’t really care. This show is insulting to Star Wars and to storytelling and represents everything which is wrong with most of modern productions, not just Star Wars.

So imagine how interested I am of talking back your arguments for a specific line of dialogue that would be explained because A led to B and along C there was D to explain E could make F be G…

I didn’t create my own patch. Anakin becoming Darth Vader and only identifying as such between Episode III and VI is literally right there, in the films and in the series.

It seems to upset you that I’m content enjoying this Star Wars series for what it is - massively inferior to the 1977 film, but still very entertaining and successful at doing what it sets out to do - without bothering to go all pseudo-analytical on it or listening to what some online critic has to say so I can become one of the enlightened haters. I didn’t address any of the other “problems” because they don’t bother me to the extent that you seem to think they should.

In that light, I am admittedly finding it hard to imagine why you wouldn’t want to waste time on providing a counterargument, cause you seem to be into wasting plenty of time on pointless gatekeeping already…